Pinecrest, FL

What Pinecrest is actually like

Long before it was Pinecrest, the area served as a staging ground for Henry Flagler’s Over-Sea Railroad construction in the early 1900s, and its identity as a destination really crystallized in December 1936, when Franz and Louise Scherr opened Parrot Jungle — about 100 visitors paid a quarter apiece on opening day — on what is now the Pinecrest Gardens site (Source). The 1950s and ’60s brought the ranch-house-on-a-one-acre-lot development pattern that still defines the village today, as the surrounding area — then generally lumped in with greater Kendall — filled in with the low-density, heavily wooded residential streets now associated with the Pinecrest name.

Hurricane Andrew devastated the area in August 1992, and the rebuilding years that followed fed directly into a push for local control: residents Evelyn Greer and Gary Matzner led the effort to incorporate, and the Village of Pinecrest was formally created on March 12, 1996, splitting off from unincorporated Miami-Dade specifically so the community could write and enforce its own zoning — above all, the one-acre-minimum EU-1 estate lots and tree-canopy protections that keep it from redeveloping into denser subdivisions (Source). Greer became the village’s first mayor; Matzner succeeded her in 2004.

Three decades on, Pinecrest is one of the wealthiest municipalities in Florida: the 33156 ZIP code it largely shares with South Miami regularly ranks among the state’s highest-income ZIP codes, and the village’s median household income was reported at roughly $166,801 as of the 2020 American Community Survey (Source). Population has held essentially flat for two decades — about 18,388 residents in 2020, versus 19,055 in 2000 — largely because there’s little vacant land left to build on and the village’s own zoning caps density; today Pinecrest is best known for Pinecrest Gardens, a Tree City USA-certified street canopy (over 10,000 trees planted since 1997), and a public-school pipeline — Pinecrest Elementary, Palmetto Middle, Miami Palmetto Senior High — that draws families willing to pay a premium to get into its boundaries.

Home values in Pinecrest

Redfin puts Pinecrest’s median sale price at $2,423,396 as of August 2026, up 8.3% year-over-year (Source); a separate three-month Redfin snapshot ending in June 2026 showed a median of $831 per square foot and homes spending about 94 days on market before selling (Source). Zillow’s own Home Value Index for Pinecrest specifically was $2,245,702 as of July 31, 2026, up 3.9% over the past year (Source); for a wider yardstick, Zillow’s ZHVI for the whole Miami metro area was just $580,866 as of August 31, 2026, up 0.8% year-over-year (Source) — underscoring how far above the regional median Pinecrest sits. RentCafe lists Pinecrest’s average asking rent at $2,444/month, with individual listings ranging roughly from $1,600 to $3,734 for studios and running higher for one- and two-bedroom units, though a precise citywide breakdown by unit size wasn’t published (Source) — renting is very much the minority option here, since most of the village’s housing stock is single-family homes on acre lots rather than apartment buildings. That zoning is itself a cost factor worth knowing about: Pinecrest’s EU-1 estate district requires a one-acre minimum lot for most single-family construction, plus tree-removal and replacement permitting, which keeps land — rather than square footage — the dominant driver of price and makes teardown-and-rebuild projects here slower and more regulated than in unincorporated Miami-Dade (Source).

Getting around

Pinecrest posts a village-wide average Walk Score of 29, with individual addresses commonly scoring much lower given the acre-lot layout, plus a Transit Score around 23 and a Bike Score around 28 near its US-1 corridor (Source) — this is a drive-everywhere suburb by design, not an oversight.

Pinecrest FAQ